Senedd Home is no longer updated. This is an archive of the fifth Senedd (September 2017 - March 2021) and is being kept for research and information purposed only. Resultingly, information on this site may be outdated. Senedd Home is no longer updated. This is an archive of the fifth Senedd (September 2017 - March 2021) and is being kept for research and information purposed only. Resultingly, information on this site may be outdated.
Oggy Bloggy Ogwr
State of Wales
Senedd Home
Friday, June 20, 2025
  • Home
  • By Issue
    • 2017-18
      • Autumn 2017
        • Issue 1 (14/09/17)
        • Issue 2 (21/09/17)
        • Issue 3 (28/09/17)
        • Issue 4 (05/10/17)
        • Issue 5 (12/10/17)
        • Issue 6 (19/10/17)
        • Issue 7 (26/10/17)
        • Issue 8 (09/11/17)
        • Issue 9 (16/11/17)
        • Issue 10 (23/11/17)
        • Issue 11 (30/11/17)
        • Issue 12 (07/12/17)
        • Issue 13 (14/12/17)
      • Spring 2018
        • Issue 14 (11/01/18)
        • Issue 15 (18/01/18)
        • Issue 16 (25/01/17)
        • Issue 17 (01/02/18)
        • Issue 18 (08/02/18)
        • Issue 19 (15/02/18)
        • Issue 20 (01/03/18)
        • Issue 21 (08/03/18)
        • Issue 22 (15/03/18)
        • Issue 23 (22/03/18)
      • Summer 2018
        • Issue 24 (19/04/18)
        • Issue 25 (26/04/18)
        • Issue 26 (03/05/18)
        • Issue 27 (10/05/18)
        • Issue 28 (17/05/18)
        • Issue 29 (24/05/18)
        • Issue 30 (07/06/18)
        • Issue 31 (14/06/18)
        • Issue 32 (21/06/18)
        • Issue 33 (28/06/18)
        • Issue 34 (05/07/18)
        • Issue 35 (12/07/18)
        • Issue 36 (19/07/18)
    • 2018-19
      • Autumn 2018
        • Issue 37 (13/09/18)
        • Issue 38 (20/09/18)
        • Issue 39 (27/09/18)
        • Issue 40 (04/10/18)
        • Issue 41 (11/10/18)
        • Issue 42 (18/10/18)
        • Issue 43 (25/10/18)
        • Issue 44 (08/11/18)
        • Issue 45 (15/11/18)
        • Issue 46 (22/11/18)
        • Issue 47 (29/11/18)
        • Issue 48 (06/12/18)
        • Issue 49 (13/12/18)
      • Spring 2019
        • Issue 50 (10/01/19)
        • Issue 51 (17/01/19)
        • Issue 52 (24/01/19)
        • Issue 53 (31/01/19)
        • Issue 54 (07/02/19)
        • Issue 55 (14/02/19)
        • Issue 56 (21/02/19)
        • Issue 57 (07/03/19)
        • Issue 58 (14/03/19)
        • Issue 59 (21/03/19)
        • Issue 60 (28/03/19)
        • Issue 61 (04/04/19)
      • Summer 2019
        • Issue 62 (02/05/19)
        • Issue 63 (09/05/19)
        • Issue 64 (16/05/19)
        • Issue 65 (23/05/19)
        • Issue 66 (06/06/19)
        • Issue 67 (13/06/19)
        • Issue 68 (20/06/19)
        • Issue 69 (27/06/19)
        • Issue 70 (04/07/19)
        • Issue 71 (11/07/19)
        • Issue 72 (18/07/19)
    • 2019-20
      • Autumn 2019
        • Issue 73 (12/09/19)
        • Issue 74 (19/09/19)
        • Issue 75 (26/09/19)
        • Issue 76 (03/10/19)
        • Issue 77 (10/10/19)
        • Issue 78 (17/10/19)
        • Issue 79 (24/10/19)
        • Issue 80 (07/11/19)
        • Issue 81 (14/11/19)
        • Issue 82 (21/11/19)
        • Issue 83 (28/11/19)
        • Issue 84 (05/12/19)
        • Issue 85 (12/12/19)
      • Spring/Summer 2020
        • Issue 86 (09/01/20)
        • Issue 87 (16/01/20)
        • Issue 88 (23/01/20)
        • Issue 89 (30/01/20)
        • Issue 90 (06/02/20)
        • Issue 91 (13/02/20)
        • Issue 92 (27/02/20)
        • Issue 93 (05/03/20)
        • Issue 94 (12/03/20)
        • Issue 95 (19/03/20)
        • Issue 96 (26/03/20)
        • Covid-19 Emergency Senedd (31/03-19/06/20)
        • Issue 97 (25/06/20)
        • Issue 98 (02/07/20)
        • Issue 99 (09/07/20)
        • Issue 100 (16/07/20)
    • 2020-21
      • Autumn 2020
        • Issue 101 (10/09/20)
        • Issue 102 (17/09/20)
        • Issue 103 (24/09/20)
        • Issue 104 (01/10/20)
        • Issue 105 (08/10/20)
        • Issue 106 (15/10/20)
        • Issue 107 (22/10/20)
        • Issue 108 (05/11/20)
        • Issue 109 (12/11/20)
        • Issue 110 (19/11/20)
        • Issue 111 (26/11/20)
        • Issue 112 (03/12/20)
        • Issue 113 (10/12/20)
        • Issue 114 (17/12/20)
      • Spring 2021
        • Issue 115 (14/01/21)
        • Issue 116 (21/01/21)
        • Issue 117 (28/01/21)
        • Issue 118 (04/02/21)
        • Issue 119 (11/02/21)
        • Issue 120 (25/02/21)
        • Issue 121 (04/03/21)
        • Issue 122 (11/03/21)
  • Committees Index
No Result
View All Result
Senedd Home
  • Home
  • By Issue
    • 2017-18
      • Autumn 2017
        • Issue 1 (14/09/17)
        • Issue 2 (21/09/17)
        • Issue 3 (28/09/17)
        • Issue 4 (05/10/17)
        • Issue 5 (12/10/17)
        • Issue 6 (19/10/17)
        • Issue 7 (26/10/17)
        • Issue 8 (09/11/17)
        • Issue 9 (16/11/17)
        • Issue 10 (23/11/17)
        • Issue 11 (30/11/17)
        • Issue 12 (07/12/17)
        • Issue 13 (14/12/17)
      • Spring 2018
        • Issue 14 (11/01/18)
        • Issue 15 (18/01/18)
        • Issue 16 (25/01/17)
        • Issue 17 (01/02/18)
        • Issue 18 (08/02/18)
        • Issue 19 (15/02/18)
        • Issue 20 (01/03/18)
        • Issue 21 (08/03/18)
        • Issue 22 (15/03/18)
        • Issue 23 (22/03/18)
      • Summer 2018
        • Issue 24 (19/04/18)
        • Issue 25 (26/04/18)
        • Issue 26 (03/05/18)
        • Issue 27 (10/05/18)
        • Issue 28 (17/05/18)
        • Issue 29 (24/05/18)
        • Issue 30 (07/06/18)
        • Issue 31 (14/06/18)
        • Issue 32 (21/06/18)
        • Issue 33 (28/06/18)
        • Issue 34 (05/07/18)
        • Issue 35 (12/07/18)
        • Issue 36 (19/07/18)
    • 2018-19
      • Autumn 2018
        • Issue 37 (13/09/18)
        • Issue 38 (20/09/18)
        • Issue 39 (27/09/18)
        • Issue 40 (04/10/18)
        • Issue 41 (11/10/18)
        • Issue 42 (18/10/18)
        • Issue 43 (25/10/18)
        • Issue 44 (08/11/18)
        • Issue 45 (15/11/18)
        • Issue 46 (22/11/18)
        • Issue 47 (29/11/18)
        • Issue 48 (06/12/18)
        • Issue 49 (13/12/18)
      • Spring 2019
        • Issue 50 (10/01/19)
        • Issue 51 (17/01/19)
        • Issue 52 (24/01/19)
        • Issue 53 (31/01/19)
        • Issue 54 (07/02/19)
        • Issue 55 (14/02/19)
        • Issue 56 (21/02/19)
        • Issue 57 (07/03/19)
        • Issue 58 (14/03/19)
        • Issue 59 (21/03/19)
        • Issue 60 (28/03/19)
        • Issue 61 (04/04/19)
      • Summer 2019
        • Issue 62 (02/05/19)
        • Issue 63 (09/05/19)
        • Issue 64 (16/05/19)
        • Issue 65 (23/05/19)
        • Issue 66 (06/06/19)
        • Issue 67 (13/06/19)
        • Issue 68 (20/06/19)
        • Issue 69 (27/06/19)
        • Issue 70 (04/07/19)
        • Issue 71 (11/07/19)
        • Issue 72 (18/07/19)
    • 2019-20
      • Autumn 2019
        • Issue 73 (12/09/19)
        • Issue 74 (19/09/19)
        • Issue 75 (26/09/19)
        • Issue 76 (03/10/19)
        • Issue 77 (10/10/19)
        • Issue 78 (17/10/19)
        • Issue 79 (24/10/19)
        • Issue 80 (07/11/19)
        • Issue 81 (14/11/19)
        • Issue 82 (21/11/19)
        • Issue 83 (28/11/19)
        • Issue 84 (05/12/19)
        • Issue 85 (12/12/19)
      • Spring/Summer 2020
        • Issue 86 (09/01/20)
        • Issue 87 (16/01/20)
        • Issue 88 (23/01/20)
        • Issue 89 (30/01/20)
        • Issue 90 (06/02/20)
        • Issue 91 (13/02/20)
        • Issue 92 (27/02/20)
        • Issue 93 (05/03/20)
        • Issue 94 (12/03/20)
        • Issue 95 (19/03/20)
        • Issue 96 (26/03/20)
        • Covid-19 Emergency Senedd (31/03-19/06/20)
        • Issue 97 (25/06/20)
        • Issue 98 (02/07/20)
        • Issue 99 (09/07/20)
        • Issue 100 (16/07/20)
    • 2020-21
      • Autumn 2020
        • Issue 101 (10/09/20)
        • Issue 102 (17/09/20)
        • Issue 103 (24/09/20)
        • Issue 104 (01/10/20)
        • Issue 105 (08/10/20)
        • Issue 106 (15/10/20)
        • Issue 107 (22/10/20)
        • Issue 108 (05/11/20)
        • Issue 109 (12/11/20)
        • Issue 110 (19/11/20)
        • Issue 111 (26/11/20)
        • Issue 112 (03/12/20)
        • Issue 113 (10/12/20)
        • Issue 114 (17/12/20)
      • Spring 2021
        • Issue 115 (14/01/21)
        • Issue 116 (21/01/21)
        • Issue 117 (28/01/21)
        • Issue 118 (04/02/21)
        • Issue 119 (11/02/21)
        • Issue 120 (25/02/21)
        • Issue 121 (04/03/21)
        • Issue 122 (11/03/21)
  • Committees Index
No Result
View All Result
Senedd Home
No Result
View All Result
Home Editorial

The Talking Point #17: Carl Sargeant inquiries not off to the best start

Owen Donovan by Owen Donovan
January 31, 2018
in Editorial, First Minister, Hot Button, The Lobby
0
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Reddit



(Title Image: Modified from BBC Wales)

As I’ve recently said, the short-term future of the First Minister depends on the outcomes of the (as far as I know) three separate investigations into the circumstances leading up to the death of Carl Sargeant.

The first such inquiry – which was to determine whether information about the November 2017 reshuffle was leaked – reported back last week.

Permanent Secretary (head of the civil service in Wales), Shan Morgan, announced that following an investigation by the Chief Security Officer, no “unauthorised” leaks of information occurred prior to the reshuffle.

Everyone with an active interest in Welsh politics and who also uses Twitter knows any suggestion there was no leak of information at all is complete and utter nonsense.

The First Minister’s dismissals in FMQs yesterday were laughable and pitiful. I say that as someone who has, on record, said he should be given a fair hearing – but he has to help himself.

Using Carwyn’s favourite phrase, “What we know” is that there was no unauthorised leak, but the findings from this first investigation raise more questions because journalists and lobbyists were proactively discussing the possibility of who was coming and going prior to it happening.

The big remaining question being “How did they get that information?” Based on there being no “unauthorised” leaks, there are several possibilities.

Firstly, their powers of prediction are unparalleled. Secondly, they heard the news unofficially (such as by eavesdropping conversations or by second/third-hand accounts).

Thirdly, there was an inevitability about Carl Sargeant’s departure due to the length of time he’s been in office; people just put 2+2 together (an educated guess) and were right.

Fourthly – as is now being speculated due to the barristerial use of the word “unauthorised” – a leak was authorised, meaning the First Minister or someone around him gave the OK to release the information. This has also been denied, but clearly hasn’t been investigated otherwise it would’ve been mentioned as part of the report’s findings.

Friends and colleagues of Carl Sargeant are quite understandably not satisfied by the conclusions of the first inquiry. The Tories have demanded a redacted report be released (the fact it hasn’t is yet another unusual oversight, though the argument goes that the evidence itself would identify the individuals involved even if redacted; how convenient).

Witnesses from within Labour have also reportedly said via the BBC they fear “repercussions” from the party if they give evidence to the James Hamilton-led inquiry into whether the First Minister breached the Ministerial Code (which will probably determine how long Carwyn stays in his job).

“I didn’t see nuthin'”.

Is this a government, or Goodfellas?

The Thick of It wasn’t supposed to act as a training video for “How To Do Politics”.

If this is going to be the standard of investigation from now on then you’ve got to raise the word that the First Minister, civil service and Welsh Labour don’t want to hear or see at all mentioned in relation to this: “whitewash”.

I suppose we’re lucky it’s now out of Cathays Park’s hands, right?

Tags: Civil ServiceFirst MinisterIssue 17LabourSargeant InquiriesThe Talking Point
ShareTweetShareSend

Archive Categories

Tags

Brexit (323) Brexit Party (153) Business Support & Finance (113) Bus Services (74) Cardiff (96) Carmarthenshire (85) Climate Change (73) Conservatives (917) Coronavirus Pandemic 2020-22 (267) Devolved Powers (104) Disability (80) Economy Department (282) Education Department (129) Emergency Senedd (Pandemic) (74) Employment & Skills (124) Environment Department (150) Farming (73) Finance Department (107) First Minister (271) FMQs (115) Health Department (262) Hospital Services (135) Iaith Gymraeg (88) Independents (197) Labour (1191) Lib Dems (159) Local Government (200) Local Government Finance (89) Local Health Boards (111) Mental Health (102) Plaid Cymru (932) Planning (82) Public Health (204) Public Services Department (141) Rail Franchise & Rail Services (91) School Curriculum (84) Senedd Commission (113) Social & Affordable Housing (68) Social Care (100) Tackling Poverty (75) Tax (98) Trade (87) UK Government (162) UKIP (168) Universities (86)
Facebook Twitter Youtube

Copyright

Creative Commons Licence


Senedd Home by Owen Donovan is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Archive

Categories

  • Best of the Blogs (114)
  • Brexit & External Affairs (180)
  • Communities & Housing (176)
  • Criminal Justice & Public Safety (73)
  • Culture, Media & Sport (103)
  • Democracy & Constitution (120)
  • Economy & Transport (334)
  • Editorial (64)
  • Education (151)
  • Environment, Energy & Rural Affairs (186)
  • Equality & Social Justice (167)
  • Finance (137)
  • First Minister (201)
  • Health & Social Services (352)
  • Hot Button (87)
  • Senedd Bites (124)
  • The Lobby (173)
  • Video (248)

© 2025 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Go to State of Wales
  • Go to Oggy Bloggy Ogwr
  • Best of the Blogs
  • Brexit & External Affairs
  • Communities & Housing
  • Criminal Justice & Public Safety
  • Culture, Media & Sport
  • Democracy & Constitution
  • Economy & Transport
  • Editorial
  • Education
  • Environment, Energy & Rural Affairs
  • Equality & Social Justice
  • Finance
  • First Minister
  • Health & Social Services
  • Senedd Bites
  • The Lobby
  • Video