Senedd Home is no longer updated. This is an archive of the fifth Senedd (September 2017 - March 2021) and is being kept for research and information purposed only. Resultingly, information on this site may be outdated. Senedd Home is no longer updated. This is an archive of the fifth Senedd (September 2017 - March 2021) and is being kept for research and information purposed only. Resultingly, information on this site may be outdated.
Oggy Bloggy Ogwr
State of Wales
Senedd Home
Friday, June 20, 2025
  • Home
  • By Issue
    • 2017-18
      • Autumn 2017
        • Issue 1 (14/09/17)
        • Issue 2 (21/09/17)
        • Issue 3 (28/09/17)
        • Issue 4 (05/10/17)
        • Issue 5 (12/10/17)
        • Issue 6 (19/10/17)
        • Issue 7 (26/10/17)
        • Issue 8 (09/11/17)
        • Issue 9 (16/11/17)
        • Issue 10 (23/11/17)
        • Issue 11 (30/11/17)
        • Issue 12 (07/12/17)
        • Issue 13 (14/12/17)
      • Spring 2018
        • Issue 14 (11/01/18)
        • Issue 15 (18/01/18)
        • Issue 16 (25/01/17)
        • Issue 17 (01/02/18)
        • Issue 18 (08/02/18)
        • Issue 19 (15/02/18)
        • Issue 20 (01/03/18)
        • Issue 21 (08/03/18)
        • Issue 22 (15/03/18)
        • Issue 23 (22/03/18)
      • Summer 2018
        • Issue 24 (19/04/18)
        • Issue 25 (26/04/18)
        • Issue 26 (03/05/18)
        • Issue 27 (10/05/18)
        • Issue 28 (17/05/18)
        • Issue 29 (24/05/18)
        • Issue 30 (07/06/18)
        • Issue 31 (14/06/18)
        • Issue 32 (21/06/18)
        • Issue 33 (28/06/18)
        • Issue 34 (05/07/18)
        • Issue 35 (12/07/18)
        • Issue 36 (19/07/18)
    • 2018-19
      • Autumn 2018
        • Issue 37 (13/09/18)
        • Issue 38 (20/09/18)
        • Issue 39 (27/09/18)
        • Issue 40 (04/10/18)
        • Issue 41 (11/10/18)
        • Issue 42 (18/10/18)
        • Issue 43 (25/10/18)
        • Issue 44 (08/11/18)
        • Issue 45 (15/11/18)
        • Issue 46 (22/11/18)
        • Issue 47 (29/11/18)
        • Issue 48 (06/12/18)
        • Issue 49 (13/12/18)
      • Spring 2019
        • Issue 50 (10/01/19)
        • Issue 51 (17/01/19)
        • Issue 52 (24/01/19)
        • Issue 53 (31/01/19)
        • Issue 54 (07/02/19)
        • Issue 55 (14/02/19)
        • Issue 56 (21/02/19)
        • Issue 57 (07/03/19)
        • Issue 58 (14/03/19)
        • Issue 59 (21/03/19)
        • Issue 60 (28/03/19)
        • Issue 61 (04/04/19)
      • Summer 2019
        • Issue 62 (02/05/19)
        • Issue 63 (09/05/19)
        • Issue 64 (16/05/19)
        • Issue 65 (23/05/19)
        • Issue 66 (06/06/19)
        • Issue 67 (13/06/19)
        • Issue 68 (20/06/19)
        • Issue 69 (27/06/19)
        • Issue 70 (04/07/19)
        • Issue 71 (11/07/19)
        • Issue 72 (18/07/19)
    • 2019-20
      • Autumn 2019
        • Issue 73 (12/09/19)
        • Issue 74 (19/09/19)
        • Issue 75 (26/09/19)
        • Issue 76 (03/10/19)
        • Issue 77 (10/10/19)
        • Issue 78 (17/10/19)
        • Issue 79 (24/10/19)
        • Issue 80 (07/11/19)
        • Issue 81 (14/11/19)
        • Issue 82 (21/11/19)
        • Issue 83 (28/11/19)
        • Issue 84 (05/12/19)
        • Issue 85 (12/12/19)
      • Spring/Summer 2020
        • Issue 86 (09/01/20)
        • Issue 87 (16/01/20)
        • Issue 88 (23/01/20)
        • Issue 89 (30/01/20)
        • Issue 90 (06/02/20)
        • Issue 91 (13/02/20)
        • Issue 92 (27/02/20)
        • Issue 93 (05/03/20)
        • Issue 94 (12/03/20)
        • Issue 95 (19/03/20)
        • Issue 96 (26/03/20)
        • Covid-19 Emergency Senedd (31/03-19/06/20)
        • Issue 97 (25/06/20)
        • Issue 98 (02/07/20)
        • Issue 99 (09/07/20)
        • Issue 100 (16/07/20)
    • 2020-21
      • Autumn 2020
        • Issue 101 (10/09/20)
        • Issue 102 (17/09/20)
        • Issue 103 (24/09/20)
        • Issue 104 (01/10/20)
        • Issue 105 (08/10/20)
        • Issue 106 (15/10/20)
        • Issue 107 (22/10/20)
        • Issue 108 (05/11/20)
        • Issue 109 (12/11/20)
        • Issue 110 (19/11/20)
        • Issue 111 (26/11/20)
        • Issue 112 (03/12/20)
        • Issue 113 (10/12/20)
        • Issue 114 (17/12/20)
      • Spring 2021
        • Issue 115 (14/01/21)
        • Issue 116 (21/01/21)
        • Issue 117 (28/01/21)
        • Issue 118 (04/02/21)
        • Issue 119 (11/02/21)
        • Issue 120 (25/02/21)
        • Issue 121 (04/03/21)
        • Issue 122 (11/03/21)
  • Committees Index
No Result
View All Result
Senedd Home
  • Home
  • By Issue
    • 2017-18
      • Autumn 2017
        • Issue 1 (14/09/17)
        • Issue 2 (21/09/17)
        • Issue 3 (28/09/17)
        • Issue 4 (05/10/17)
        • Issue 5 (12/10/17)
        • Issue 6 (19/10/17)
        • Issue 7 (26/10/17)
        • Issue 8 (09/11/17)
        • Issue 9 (16/11/17)
        • Issue 10 (23/11/17)
        • Issue 11 (30/11/17)
        • Issue 12 (07/12/17)
        • Issue 13 (14/12/17)
      • Spring 2018
        • Issue 14 (11/01/18)
        • Issue 15 (18/01/18)
        • Issue 16 (25/01/17)
        • Issue 17 (01/02/18)
        • Issue 18 (08/02/18)
        • Issue 19 (15/02/18)
        • Issue 20 (01/03/18)
        • Issue 21 (08/03/18)
        • Issue 22 (15/03/18)
        • Issue 23 (22/03/18)
      • Summer 2018
        • Issue 24 (19/04/18)
        • Issue 25 (26/04/18)
        • Issue 26 (03/05/18)
        • Issue 27 (10/05/18)
        • Issue 28 (17/05/18)
        • Issue 29 (24/05/18)
        • Issue 30 (07/06/18)
        • Issue 31 (14/06/18)
        • Issue 32 (21/06/18)
        • Issue 33 (28/06/18)
        • Issue 34 (05/07/18)
        • Issue 35 (12/07/18)
        • Issue 36 (19/07/18)
    • 2018-19
      • Autumn 2018
        • Issue 37 (13/09/18)
        • Issue 38 (20/09/18)
        • Issue 39 (27/09/18)
        • Issue 40 (04/10/18)
        • Issue 41 (11/10/18)
        • Issue 42 (18/10/18)
        • Issue 43 (25/10/18)
        • Issue 44 (08/11/18)
        • Issue 45 (15/11/18)
        • Issue 46 (22/11/18)
        • Issue 47 (29/11/18)
        • Issue 48 (06/12/18)
        • Issue 49 (13/12/18)
      • Spring 2019
        • Issue 50 (10/01/19)
        • Issue 51 (17/01/19)
        • Issue 52 (24/01/19)
        • Issue 53 (31/01/19)
        • Issue 54 (07/02/19)
        • Issue 55 (14/02/19)
        • Issue 56 (21/02/19)
        • Issue 57 (07/03/19)
        • Issue 58 (14/03/19)
        • Issue 59 (21/03/19)
        • Issue 60 (28/03/19)
        • Issue 61 (04/04/19)
      • Summer 2019
        • Issue 62 (02/05/19)
        • Issue 63 (09/05/19)
        • Issue 64 (16/05/19)
        • Issue 65 (23/05/19)
        • Issue 66 (06/06/19)
        • Issue 67 (13/06/19)
        • Issue 68 (20/06/19)
        • Issue 69 (27/06/19)
        • Issue 70 (04/07/19)
        • Issue 71 (11/07/19)
        • Issue 72 (18/07/19)
    • 2019-20
      • Autumn 2019
        • Issue 73 (12/09/19)
        • Issue 74 (19/09/19)
        • Issue 75 (26/09/19)
        • Issue 76 (03/10/19)
        • Issue 77 (10/10/19)
        • Issue 78 (17/10/19)
        • Issue 79 (24/10/19)
        • Issue 80 (07/11/19)
        • Issue 81 (14/11/19)
        • Issue 82 (21/11/19)
        • Issue 83 (28/11/19)
        • Issue 84 (05/12/19)
        • Issue 85 (12/12/19)
      • Spring/Summer 2020
        • Issue 86 (09/01/20)
        • Issue 87 (16/01/20)
        • Issue 88 (23/01/20)
        • Issue 89 (30/01/20)
        • Issue 90 (06/02/20)
        • Issue 91 (13/02/20)
        • Issue 92 (27/02/20)
        • Issue 93 (05/03/20)
        • Issue 94 (12/03/20)
        • Issue 95 (19/03/20)
        • Issue 96 (26/03/20)
        • Covid-19 Emergency Senedd (31/03-19/06/20)
        • Issue 97 (25/06/20)
        • Issue 98 (02/07/20)
        • Issue 99 (09/07/20)
        • Issue 100 (16/07/20)
    • 2020-21
      • Autumn 2020
        • Issue 101 (10/09/20)
        • Issue 102 (17/09/20)
        • Issue 103 (24/09/20)
        • Issue 104 (01/10/20)
        • Issue 105 (08/10/20)
        • Issue 106 (15/10/20)
        • Issue 107 (22/10/20)
        • Issue 108 (05/11/20)
        • Issue 109 (12/11/20)
        • Issue 110 (19/11/20)
        • Issue 111 (26/11/20)
        • Issue 112 (03/12/20)
        • Issue 113 (10/12/20)
        • Issue 114 (17/12/20)
      • Spring 2021
        • Issue 115 (14/01/21)
        • Issue 116 (21/01/21)
        • Issue 117 (28/01/21)
        • Issue 118 (04/02/21)
        • Issue 119 (11/02/21)
        • Issue 120 (25/02/21)
        • Issue 121 (04/03/21)
        • Issue 122 (11/03/21)
  • Committees Index
No Result
View All Result
Senedd Home
No Result
View All Result
Home First Minister

Senedd backs call for Carl Sargeant “leak” report to be released

Owen Donovan by Owen Donovan
March 1, 2018
in First Minister, Hot Button, The Lobby
0
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Reddit



The Issue

A few weeks ago the first report into the Carl Sargeant affair – on whether there had been a leak of information prior to the November 2017 reshuffle – reported back. Authored by the Permanent Secretary, Shan Morgan, the report concluded there had been no unofficial leaks.

I’m not going to repeat what I said at the time, but my reaction is in Carl Sargeant inquiries not off to the best start.

The Welsh Conservatives and Plaid Cymru tabled a joint motion calling for a redacted version of the report to be released/published (though presumably only to AMs and not the public). The Welsh Government have so far refused to do so as they believe even a redacted version could lead to complainants being identified.

The Motion

The Senedd:

  • Calls on the Permanent Secretary to publish, with appropriate redactions to ensure anonymity of witnesses, the report into her investigation on ‘whether there is any evidence of a prior unauthorised sharing of information—i.e. a “leak”—by the Welsh Government of information relating to the ….reshuffle’.

Key Points

Andrew RT Davies AM (Con, South Wales Central)
For (the motion): It’s an AM’s duty to scrutinise.

  • It’s the duty of AMs to properly scrutinise organisations that have allegations made against them.
  • It’s a “reasonable request” to see the report itself, its methodology, its conclusions and any action taken since.
  • A number of sources put information into the public domain around the reshuffle, including journalists and lobbyists.
  • Lobbyist firm, Deryn Consulting, reportedly had information on the reshuffle prior to it happening and journalists received a text from a Deryn employee who said Carl Sargeant would lose his job.
  • He hasn’t received a response from the Permanent Secretary to letters he sent over a month ago.

Llyr Gruffydd AM (Plaid, North Wales)
For: Let’s set a higher standard for ourselves and our government.

  • The findings of the inquiry are a matter of public interest.
  • Openness, transparency and accountability are key principles of public life; leaders should also promote these principles through their own actions. “If Carwyn Jones has nothing to hide then he should have nothing to fear from publishing the report”.
  • Where does it leave democracy if these opposition debates and motions are ignored?
  • It isn’t right for the First Minister to be “judge, jury and executioner” with regard the Ministerial Code.

Neil Hamilton AM (UKIP, Mid & West Wales)
Mixed-views: The report should be published, but it’s unlikely to get to the truth.

  • It’s difficult to see how anyone with a good conscience could oppose the motion.
  • He has prior experience of internal inquiries into leaks and so on and they never get to the truth; civil servants aren’t trained to be detectives.
  • The system of special advisors is geared towards people exceeding their authority because they think it’s what Ministers want.

Lee Waters AM (Lab, Llanelli)
Against: This is political game-playing.

  • He believes the text message he received prior to the reshuffle was “gossip” and wasn’t from an official source. He didn’t take it seriously until news of Carl Sargeant’s sacking broke.
  • He won’t give the name of the source because he doesn’t want to “leave a trail of breadcrumbs” which could lead to complainants being identified.
  • The inquiry by Paul Bowen QC should be the proper avenue to handle the report.
  • “The women have been forgotten in this”; even a redacted report could lead to them being identified – the whole thing is becoming subject to political game-playing.

Darren Millar AM (Con, Clwyd West)
For: We need the truth.

  • This isn’t political point-scoring, but about getting to the truth of what happened.
  • This was the only time in his tenure as an AM that information about a reshuffle was disseminated in this manner; it was clear there wasn’t just gossip and speculation but hard information being shared.
  • The Permanent Secretary should give an account to AMs on how she conducted the inquiry.

Rhun ap Iorwerth AM (Plaid, Ynys Môn)
For: Labour shouldn’t write this off as a “meaningless debate”.

  • Key questions remain unanswered about the handling of the reshuffle. More texts have come to light that shows Carl Sargeant was aware the reshuffle was coming.
  • If the motion is supported, the Government should act on the Senedd’s will not ignore it or consider it “meaningless”.

Welsh Government Response

Leader of the House, Julie James (Lab, Swansea West)

  • Publication of the report could prejudice other inquiries and make individuals less confident about giving evidence.
  • A copy of the report will be made available to Paul Bowen QC.

Vote

The vote carried despite a large number of abstentions (which count as a “non-vote”). This doesn’t mean the Welsh Government or Permanent Secretary will actually publish the report as the vote is non-binding. As you would probably be interested to know, Jack Sargeant AM (Lab, Alyn & Deeside) abstained in line with his party.


Tags: 2017 Bullying & Harassment ScandalCivil ServiceConservativesFirst MinisterIssue 20LabourLeader of the HouseLobbying & Public AffairsPlaid CymruSargeant InquiriesUKIP
ShareTweetShareSend

Archive Categories

Tags

Brexit (323) Brexit Party (153) Business Support & Finance (113) Bus Services (74) Cardiff (96) Carmarthenshire (85) Climate Change (73) Conservatives (917) Coronavirus Pandemic 2020-22 (267) Devolved Powers (104) Disability (80) Economy Department (282) Education Department (129) Emergency Senedd (Pandemic) (74) Employment & Skills (124) Environment Department (150) Farming (73) Finance Department (107) First Minister (271) FMQs (115) Health Department (262) Hospital Services (135) Iaith Gymraeg (88) Independents (197) Labour (1191) Lib Dems (159) Local Government (200) Local Government Finance (89) Local Health Boards (111) Mental Health (102) Plaid Cymru (932) Planning (82) Public Health (204) Public Services Department (141) Rail Franchise & Rail Services (91) School Curriculum (84) Senedd Commission (113) Social & Affordable Housing (68) Social Care (100) Tackling Poverty (75) Tax (98) Trade (87) UK Government (162) UKIP (168) Universities (86)
Facebook Twitter Youtube

Copyright

Creative Commons Licence


Senedd Home by Owen Donovan is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Archive

Categories

  • Best of the Blogs (114)
  • Brexit & External Affairs (180)
  • Communities & Housing (176)
  • Criminal Justice & Public Safety (73)
  • Culture, Media & Sport (103)
  • Democracy & Constitution (120)
  • Economy & Transport (334)
  • Editorial (64)
  • Education (151)
  • Environment, Energy & Rural Affairs (186)
  • Equality & Social Justice (167)
  • Finance (137)
  • First Minister (201)
  • Health & Social Services (352)
  • Hot Button (87)
  • Senedd Bites (124)
  • The Lobby (173)
  • Video (248)

© 2025 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Go to State of Wales
  • Go to Oggy Bloggy Ogwr
  • Best of the Blogs
  • Brexit & External Affairs
  • Communities & Housing
  • Criminal Justice & Public Safety
  • Culture, Media & Sport
  • Democracy & Constitution
  • Economy & Transport
  • Editorial
  • Education
  • Environment, Energy & Rural Affairs
  • Equality & Social Justice
  • Finance
  • First Minister
  • Health & Social Services
  • Senedd Bites
  • The Lobby
  • Video