/AMs debate anti-opencast petition report

AMs debate anti-opencast petition report



(Title Image: Coflein Mapping)

P-04-472 “Make the MTAN law” P-04-575 “Call in All Opencast Mining Planning Applications”
Submitted by Dr John Cox, United Valleys Action Group
Signatures: 7,360 (combined – online)

Petition Supporting Evidence

Petitions Committee Report (link)

  • Putting a 500-metre buffer zone between opencast mines and residential areas isn’t currently mandatory in Welsh planning law.
  • The Welsh Government should call-in plans for opencast mines due to the effect they have beyond the immediate local area.

Key Points

Chair of the Petitions Committee, David Rowlands AM (UKIP, South Wales East)

  • The application for an opencast site near Varteg in Torfaen breached guidance in the MTAN 2 (planning guidance for mining) in relation to the buffer zone.
  • The Planning Inspectorate ignored MTAN guidance when the developer’s appeal (against its rejected planning application by Torfaen Council) was successful.
  • Calling in all opencast mines and reviewing them would ensure consistency in planning decisions.
  • There are a number of examples of inadequate restoration of opencast sites; both petitioners argued more needed to be done and supported an upfront deposit scheme for restoration – which isn’t currently included in new draft planning guidelines for Wales.

Lynne Neagle AM (Lab, Torfaen)

  • The Varteg decision by the Planning Inspectorate flew in the face of Welsh Government guidance.
  • She hopes we won’t see any new opencast applications.
  • Lynne criticised the length of time it’s taken the petition to get this far – up to five years.

Mark Reckless AM (Con, South Wales East)

  • Planning guidance allows for a sensible level of local discretion and these decisions are better taken by local planning committees than handing down statutory/mandatory guidance.
  • What would happen if the UK or Welsh government decided that coal was needed to ensure energy security?
  • The Welsh Government should consider offering more planning support to smaller local authorities.

Dawn Bowden AM (Lab, Merthyr Tydfil & Rhymney)

  • The landscape around Merthyr has completely changed due to the Ffos-y-Fran opencast site; there’s a very clear public interest that mine owners properly restore sites after use and the Welsh Government/local authorities should ensure money is set aside to fund works.

Bethan Sayed AM (Plaid, South Wales West)

  • Mining companies have gotten away with “criminal” neglect of opencast sites after use – there are numerous examples.
  • MTAN should be replaced by a new law; as long as it’s just guidance local authorities and the Planning Inspectorate will be able to find exceptions.

Gareth Bennett AM (UKIP, South Wales Central)

  • The planning system is undemocratic and technocratic with decisions made by bureaucrats, overturning decisions made by planning committees.
  • UKIP supports legally-binding local referendums for major planning applications.

Welsh Government Response

Energy, Planning & Rural Affairs Secretary, Lesley Griffiths (Lab, Wrexham)

  • New planning guidance will be restrictive and discourage future planning applications for opencast mines – it’ll also apply to applications currently awaiting decisions.
  • The Welsh Government won’t have to use call-in powers if applications are discouraged.
  • Policies in relation to restoration will be strengthened, including “financial security” to secure restoration.

Vote

The report was unanimously noted.

Like this work? Why not consider supporting Senedd Home on Patreon?