Senedd Home is no longer updated. This is an archive of the fifth Senedd (September 2017 - March 2021) and is being kept for research and information purposed only. Resultingly, information on this site may be outdated. Senedd Home is no longer updated. This is an archive of the fifth Senedd (September 2017 - March 2021) and is being kept for research and information purposed only. Resultingly, information on this site may be outdated.
Oggy Bloggy Ogwr
State of Wales
Senedd Home
Friday, June 20, 2025
  • Home
  • By Issue
    • 2017-18
      • Autumn 2017
        • Issue 1 (14/09/17)
        • Issue 2 (21/09/17)
        • Issue 3 (28/09/17)
        • Issue 4 (05/10/17)
        • Issue 5 (12/10/17)
        • Issue 6 (19/10/17)
        • Issue 7 (26/10/17)
        • Issue 8 (09/11/17)
        • Issue 9 (16/11/17)
        • Issue 10 (23/11/17)
        • Issue 11 (30/11/17)
        • Issue 12 (07/12/17)
        • Issue 13 (14/12/17)
      • Spring 2018
        • Issue 14 (11/01/18)
        • Issue 15 (18/01/18)
        • Issue 16 (25/01/17)
        • Issue 17 (01/02/18)
        • Issue 18 (08/02/18)
        • Issue 19 (15/02/18)
        • Issue 20 (01/03/18)
        • Issue 21 (08/03/18)
        • Issue 22 (15/03/18)
        • Issue 23 (22/03/18)
      • Summer 2018
        • Issue 24 (19/04/18)
        • Issue 25 (26/04/18)
        • Issue 26 (03/05/18)
        • Issue 27 (10/05/18)
        • Issue 28 (17/05/18)
        • Issue 29 (24/05/18)
        • Issue 30 (07/06/18)
        • Issue 31 (14/06/18)
        • Issue 32 (21/06/18)
        • Issue 33 (28/06/18)
        • Issue 34 (05/07/18)
        • Issue 35 (12/07/18)
        • Issue 36 (19/07/18)
    • 2018-19
      • Autumn 2018
        • Issue 37 (13/09/18)
        • Issue 38 (20/09/18)
        • Issue 39 (27/09/18)
        • Issue 40 (04/10/18)
        • Issue 41 (11/10/18)
        • Issue 42 (18/10/18)
        • Issue 43 (25/10/18)
        • Issue 44 (08/11/18)
        • Issue 45 (15/11/18)
        • Issue 46 (22/11/18)
        • Issue 47 (29/11/18)
        • Issue 48 (06/12/18)
        • Issue 49 (13/12/18)
      • Spring 2019
        • Issue 50 (10/01/19)
        • Issue 51 (17/01/19)
        • Issue 52 (24/01/19)
        • Issue 53 (31/01/19)
        • Issue 54 (07/02/19)
        • Issue 55 (14/02/19)
        • Issue 56 (21/02/19)
        • Issue 57 (07/03/19)
        • Issue 58 (14/03/19)
        • Issue 59 (21/03/19)
        • Issue 60 (28/03/19)
        • Issue 61 (04/04/19)
      • Summer 2019
        • Issue 62 (02/05/19)
        • Issue 63 (09/05/19)
        • Issue 64 (16/05/19)
        • Issue 65 (23/05/19)
        • Issue 66 (06/06/19)
        • Issue 67 (13/06/19)
        • Issue 68 (20/06/19)
        • Issue 69 (27/06/19)
        • Issue 70 (04/07/19)
        • Issue 71 (11/07/19)
        • Issue 72 (18/07/19)
    • 2019-20
      • Autumn 2019
        • Issue 73 (12/09/19)
        • Issue 74 (19/09/19)
        • Issue 75 (26/09/19)
        • Issue 76 (03/10/19)
        • Issue 77 (10/10/19)
        • Issue 78 (17/10/19)
        • Issue 79 (24/10/19)
        • Issue 80 (07/11/19)
        • Issue 81 (14/11/19)
        • Issue 82 (21/11/19)
        • Issue 83 (28/11/19)
        • Issue 84 (05/12/19)
        • Issue 85 (12/12/19)
      • Spring/Summer 2020
        • Issue 86 (09/01/20)
        • Issue 87 (16/01/20)
        • Issue 88 (23/01/20)
        • Issue 89 (30/01/20)
        • Issue 90 (06/02/20)
        • Issue 91 (13/02/20)
        • Issue 92 (27/02/20)
        • Issue 93 (05/03/20)
        • Issue 94 (12/03/20)
        • Issue 95 (19/03/20)
        • Issue 96 (26/03/20)
        • Covid-19 Emergency Senedd (31/03-19/06/20)
        • Issue 97 (25/06/20)
        • Issue 98 (02/07/20)
        • Issue 99 (09/07/20)
        • Issue 100 (16/07/20)
    • 2020-21
      • Autumn 2020
        • Issue 101 (10/09/20)
        • Issue 102 (17/09/20)
        • Issue 103 (24/09/20)
        • Issue 104 (01/10/20)
        • Issue 105 (08/10/20)
        • Issue 106 (15/10/20)
        • Issue 107 (22/10/20)
        • Issue 108 (05/11/20)
        • Issue 109 (12/11/20)
        • Issue 110 (19/11/20)
        • Issue 111 (26/11/20)
        • Issue 112 (03/12/20)
        • Issue 113 (10/12/20)
        • Issue 114 (17/12/20)
      • Spring 2021
        • Issue 115 (14/01/21)
        • Issue 116 (21/01/21)
        • Issue 117 (28/01/21)
        • Issue 118 (04/02/21)
        • Issue 119 (11/02/21)
        • Issue 120 (25/02/21)
        • Issue 121 (04/03/21)
        • Issue 122 (11/03/21)
  • Committees Index
No Result
View All Result
Senedd Home
  • Home
  • By Issue
    • 2017-18
      • Autumn 2017
        • Issue 1 (14/09/17)
        • Issue 2 (21/09/17)
        • Issue 3 (28/09/17)
        • Issue 4 (05/10/17)
        • Issue 5 (12/10/17)
        • Issue 6 (19/10/17)
        • Issue 7 (26/10/17)
        • Issue 8 (09/11/17)
        • Issue 9 (16/11/17)
        • Issue 10 (23/11/17)
        • Issue 11 (30/11/17)
        • Issue 12 (07/12/17)
        • Issue 13 (14/12/17)
      • Spring 2018
        • Issue 14 (11/01/18)
        • Issue 15 (18/01/18)
        • Issue 16 (25/01/17)
        • Issue 17 (01/02/18)
        • Issue 18 (08/02/18)
        • Issue 19 (15/02/18)
        • Issue 20 (01/03/18)
        • Issue 21 (08/03/18)
        • Issue 22 (15/03/18)
        • Issue 23 (22/03/18)
      • Summer 2018
        • Issue 24 (19/04/18)
        • Issue 25 (26/04/18)
        • Issue 26 (03/05/18)
        • Issue 27 (10/05/18)
        • Issue 28 (17/05/18)
        • Issue 29 (24/05/18)
        • Issue 30 (07/06/18)
        • Issue 31 (14/06/18)
        • Issue 32 (21/06/18)
        • Issue 33 (28/06/18)
        • Issue 34 (05/07/18)
        • Issue 35 (12/07/18)
        • Issue 36 (19/07/18)
    • 2018-19
      • Autumn 2018
        • Issue 37 (13/09/18)
        • Issue 38 (20/09/18)
        • Issue 39 (27/09/18)
        • Issue 40 (04/10/18)
        • Issue 41 (11/10/18)
        • Issue 42 (18/10/18)
        • Issue 43 (25/10/18)
        • Issue 44 (08/11/18)
        • Issue 45 (15/11/18)
        • Issue 46 (22/11/18)
        • Issue 47 (29/11/18)
        • Issue 48 (06/12/18)
        • Issue 49 (13/12/18)
      • Spring 2019
        • Issue 50 (10/01/19)
        • Issue 51 (17/01/19)
        • Issue 52 (24/01/19)
        • Issue 53 (31/01/19)
        • Issue 54 (07/02/19)
        • Issue 55 (14/02/19)
        • Issue 56 (21/02/19)
        • Issue 57 (07/03/19)
        • Issue 58 (14/03/19)
        • Issue 59 (21/03/19)
        • Issue 60 (28/03/19)
        • Issue 61 (04/04/19)
      • Summer 2019
        • Issue 62 (02/05/19)
        • Issue 63 (09/05/19)
        • Issue 64 (16/05/19)
        • Issue 65 (23/05/19)
        • Issue 66 (06/06/19)
        • Issue 67 (13/06/19)
        • Issue 68 (20/06/19)
        • Issue 69 (27/06/19)
        • Issue 70 (04/07/19)
        • Issue 71 (11/07/19)
        • Issue 72 (18/07/19)
    • 2019-20
      • Autumn 2019
        • Issue 73 (12/09/19)
        • Issue 74 (19/09/19)
        • Issue 75 (26/09/19)
        • Issue 76 (03/10/19)
        • Issue 77 (10/10/19)
        • Issue 78 (17/10/19)
        • Issue 79 (24/10/19)
        • Issue 80 (07/11/19)
        • Issue 81 (14/11/19)
        • Issue 82 (21/11/19)
        • Issue 83 (28/11/19)
        • Issue 84 (05/12/19)
        • Issue 85 (12/12/19)
      • Spring/Summer 2020
        • Issue 86 (09/01/20)
        • Issue 87 (16/01/20)
        • Issue 88 (23/01/20)
        • Issue 89 (30/01/20)
        • Issue 90 (06/02/20)
        • Issue 91 (13/02/20)
        • Issue 92 (27/02/20)
        • Issue 93 (05/03/20)
        • Issue 94 (12/03/20)
        • Issue 95 (19/03/20)
        • Issue 96 (26/03/20)
        • Covid-19 Emergency Senedd (31/03-19/06/20)
        • Issue 97 (25/06/20)
        • Issue 98 (02/07/20)
        • Issue 99 (09/07/20)
        • Issue 100 (16/07/20)
    • 2020-21
      • Autumn 2020
        • Issue 101 (10/09/20)
        • Issue 102 (17/09/20)
        • Issue 103 (24/09/20)
        • Issue 104 (01/10/20)
        • Issue 105 (08/10/20)
        • Issue 106 (15/10/20)
        • Issue 107 (22/10/20)
        • Issue 108 (05/11/20)
        • Issue 109 (12/11/20)
        • Issue 110 (19/11/20)
        • Issue 111 (26/11/20)
        • Issue 112 (03/12/20)
        • Issue 113 (10/12/20)
        • Issue 114 (17/12/20)
      • Spring 2021
        • Issue 115 (14/01/21)
        • Issue 116 (21/01/21)
        • Issue 117 (28/01/21)
        • Issue 118 (04/02/21)
        • Issue 119 (11/02/21)
        • Issue 120 (25/02/21)
        • Issue 121 (04/03/21)
        • Issue 122 (11/03/21)
  • Committees Index
No Result
View All Result
Senedd Home
No Result
View All Result
Home Economy & Transport

Newport M4 bypass scrapped by the Welsh Government on cost grounds

Owen Donovan by Owen Donovan
June 4, 2019
in Economy & Transport, Hot Button
0
A decision on the M4 Newport bypass likely by December

Welsh Government

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Reddit

(Title Image: Welsh Government)

The latest attempt to build a Newport bypass has failed after the First Minister announced this afternoon that the Welsh Government won’t give it the go ahead.

The First Minister’s written decision is available here (pdf) alongside the inspector’s report (pdf).

Bypass couldn’t be implemented for the foreseeable future

There are obvious environmental concerns, which the First Minister said he placed greater weight on than the Planning Inspector.

However, the primary reason the project has been rejected is that the Cabinet decided on April 29th 2019 that the Welsh capital budget doesn’t go far enough to cover the projected costs (estimated at anything between £1.3-1.7billion) and could have lead to lengthy delays in starting construction and associated problems with compulsory purchase orders.

The First Minister acknowledged there was a consensus that issues in and around Newport need to be addressed and (as the Welsh solution to a problem is to form a committee) a Commission of transport experts will look at alternative solutions in detail.

In the meantime, a number of measures will be introduced to improve traffic flow around Newport including faster vehicle recovery, extra traffic officer patrols, live journey time information and a public information campaign to change driver behaviour.

Sold a pup?

Leader of the Opposition, Paul Davies AM (Con, Preseli Pembs.), said £31million was being lost to the Welsh economy every year because of the Newport M4 and – while the problem should’ve been dealt with decades ago – successive Labour governments have failed since despite £44million being spent on it.

“First Minister, you are saying that this project is now not affordable. However, last year (as Finance Minister) you wrote to the Chief Secretary to the Treasury…. asking for more money…. In this letter, you clearly thought this scheme was achievable, because….you said: ‘I will be seeking an increase in the Welsh Government’s annual and aggregate borrowing limits….. in order that we can deliver our investment priorities for Wales, including the M4 project’.”
– Leader of the Opposition, Paul Davies AM

He suggested a number of pledges have been broken, including a 2016 Labour manifesto commitment to deliver the bypass, a pledge for a binding vote amongst AMs and pledges made during Labour’s Newport West by-election campaign.

Shadow Economy Minister, Russell George AM (Con, Montgomery), accused the Welsh Government of using the Commission to “go back to square one” when the inquiry has already examined all the alternatives in great detail.

Mohammad Asghar AM (Con, South Wales East) described it as a sad day for those who want barriers to economic growth removed, haulage companies, commuters, tourists and anyone benefiting from the removal of Severn Crossing tolls. Nick Ramsay AM (Con, Monmouth) asked what would happen to land purchased as part of pre-construction work – to which the First Minister said it was now a Welsh Government asset.

There was even disappointment on the Labour benches.

Jayne Bryant AM (Lab, Newport West) described the decision as a “bitter blow” that would condemn Newport to congestion, idle traffic and air pollution. Improving public transport in Newport wouldn’t work as only 6% of M4 traffic would be removed, while accidents force more traffic through the city itself. Any money saved from this decision had to be spent in the Newport area.

Praise the repentant sinner

Although critical of the length of time taken to reach this point, Plaid Cymru backed the decision:

“I think the proper response in the first instance is to praise the repentant for seeing the error of their ways. ….We repeatedly said….that the black route was both environmentally destructive and financially unjustifiable. I think both points have borne out in the statement….It’s financially unjustifiable because, as the First Minister said, it would have siphoned such a large proportion of the limited borrowing powers that we have, and of the overstretched capital funds available to the Welsh Government.”
– Adam Price AM (Plaid, Carms. E. & Dinefwr)

John Griffiths AM (Lab, Newport East) agreed with the decision. The recently-declared climate emergency and the importance of the Gwent Levels requires new thinking. Nonetheless, he repeated Jayne Bryant’s call for the earmarked budget to be spent solving transport issues around Newport.

Meanwhile, Alun Davies AM (Lab, Blaenau Gwent) would prefer to see it spent on economic development across Gwent, while Jack Sargeant AM (Lab, Alyn & Deeside) made the case for it to be spent on a range of projects around the country.

Tags: AusterityBiodiversity & Wildlife ConservationCardiffConservativesFirst MinisterIssue 66LabourM4 Newport BypassMonmouthshireNew Road SchemesNewportPlaid CymruPlanningPlanning InspectoratePublic Borrowing & DebtRoad Network
ShareTweetShareSend

Archive Categories

Tags

Brexit (323) Brexit Party (153) Business Support & Finance (113) Bus Services (74) Cardiff (96) Carmarthenshire (85) Climate Change (73) Conservatives (917) Coronavirus Pandemic 2020-22 (267) Devolved Powers (104) Disability (80) Economy Department (282) Education Department (129) Emergency Senedd (Pandemic) (74) Employment & Skills (124) Environment Department (150) Farming (73) Finance Department (107) First Minister (271) FMQs (115) Health Department (262) Hospital Services (135) Iaith Gymraeg (88) Independents (197) Labour (1191) Lib Dems (159) Local Government (200) Local Government Finance (89) Local Health Boards (111) Mental Health (102) Plaid Cymru (932) Planning (82) Public Health (204) Public Services Department (141) Rail Franchise & Rail Services (91) School Curriculum (84) Senedd Commission (113) Social & Affordable Housing (68) Social Care (100) Tackling Poverty (75) Tax (98) Trade (87) UK Government (162) UKIP (168) Universities (86)
Facebook Twitter Youtube

Copyright

Creative Commons Licence


Senedd Home by Owen Donovan is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Archive

Categories

  • Best of the Blogs (114)
  • Brexit & External Affairs (180)
  • Communities & Housing (176)
  • Criminal Justice & Public Safety (73)
  • Culture, Media & Sport (103)
  • Democracy & Constitution (120)
  • Economy & Transport (334)
  • Editorial (64)
  • Education (151)
  • Environment, Energy & Rural Affairs (186)
  • Equality & Social Justice (167)
  • Finance (137)
  • First Minister (201)
  • Health & Social Services (352)
  • Hot Button (87)
  • Senedd Bites (124)
  • The Lobby (173)
  • Video (248)

© 2025 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Go to State of Wales
  • Go to Oggy Bloggy Ogwr
  • Best of the Blogs
  • Brexit & External Affairs
  • Communities & Housing
  • Criminal Justice & Public Safety
  • Culture, Media & Sport
  • Democracy & Constitution
  • Economy & Transport
  • Editorial
  • Education
  • Environment, Energy & Rural Affairs
  • Equality & Social Justice
  • Finance
  • First Minister
  • Health & Social Services
  • Senedd Bites
  • The Lobby
  • Video